I don’t do it so much now, but for years, I part-decanted [virtually] every bottle of whisky I bought into a small number of [3/6/15cl] sample bottles for future reference. Digging around, I fancied a ‘smoke’ and unearthed four peat-monsters from the Bruichladdich stable. Though a revisit for me, it’s the first time my thoughts about three of today’s quartet will have featured on these pages.
[Bruichladdich] Port Charlotte PC8 2001/2009 8yo Ob. ‘Ar Duthchas’ [30000 bts] 60.5% WB87.55 WF89 WM86
This is the only bottle of today’s four that I have previously reviewed on these pages [WLP87]. Let’s see how I find it five years on.
- N: There’s an easiness/familiarity to this ingredients-faithful presentation with its bourbon-y sweetness, light-farmy yet oily grain legacy, and [clean] oniony light mezcal < tequila vibes [a reoccurring theme] – albeit with a rubbery > plimsole and liquorice [tea] > ‘dunked’ Nice biscuit note.
- T&F: With some [water-manageable] bourbon gackiness on the palate, we’ve a [woody herbal lemondade-y]~bitter-sweet to a decidedly lemony sour situation. There’s a woolly touch which doesn’t detract from the elongated encapsulating pepperminty fresh gingery sour lemon viscosity on the finish with a medicinal sour conclusion.
- C: A thoroughly excellent spirit-faithful whisky if not exactly a comfort blanket dram overall. These are our future – glass-aged – classics.
Scores 89 points [going on 92 in 2045?]
[Bruichladdich] Port Charlotte PC10 2002/2012 10yo Ob. ‘Tro Na Linntean’  59.8% WB87.95 WM91 WN88
- N: A bready salty allium-y [seemingly] rum > tequila-like collaboration with the addition of a few sultanas, 1/3 teaspoon of cocoa powder and, despite Bruichladdich’s savoury nature in general, more than a suggestion of maple syrup over a few ham squares. Indeed, sweet ex-bourbon casks help subdue the phenols somewhat.
- T: Super oily yet floury/grain-dry over a salty shammy leathery belly, we’ve a heavy salted vegetal/medicinal minerallic > diluted syrupy delivery,…
- F: ,… with a gradual~growing reveal, intensely salty, and with a dirty dry garage-y savoury-sour [watered-down] golden syrup finish.
- C: Bruichladdich’s heavily peated bruisers [accompanied by a suitably complimentary high-octane abv] rarely favour the faint-hearted, this one being a prime example. For me, the highlight was the journey points between arrival and release.
Scores 88 points
[Bruichladdich] Octomore 06.1 05yo  Ob. American Oak Casks [18000 bts] 57% WB86.66 WF85
- N: Crisp vegetal farmy saltiness with a layered oak-wood vanilla wafer – Caol Ila meets Ardbeg if you will – and a Mr Whippy slowly melting over a tea-dunked Weetabix~Digestive biscuit.
- T: A crisp formidably barley-faithful single malt with soft tequila/rum vibes. The saltiness is ever-intense, though after trying all four drams, you soon acclimatise.
- F: Remaining crisp and barley/peat faithful, I pick up on an illusion of a [white] wine finish.
- C: Having not connected with this release so strongly in the past – mostly judged against the 06.2 to follow – years [and years] on, I’m far more convinced.
Scores 88 points
Last up, an Octomore favourite. It’s incredible to think this bottle cost me just £75 back in the day though the hype and subsequent price surge [£250+] peaked and cooled in the intervening years.
[Bruichladdich] Octomore 06.2 05yo  Ob. Ex-eau-de-vie Limousin oak [18000 bts] 58.2% WB86.19 WF87
Just to be clear, this youthful spirit has been aged in Ex-eau-de-vie Limousin oak casks, and not – as I’ve wrongly mentioned in the past – Limonsin ex-cognac casks.
- N: If I were to start a distillery, I might head towards this uber-oily farmy vegetal style with layered oaky phenolic lemon juice and a drop or two of apple cider > onion vinegar. Being spirit-faithful and aged to retain youthfulness and a full-bodied weighty fattiness, we find ourselves in a mature genever/mezcal-tequila territory.
- T: With an equally focused savoury and sweet coupling, we’ve a very salty farmy phenolic and bitter /sour lemon/lime shandy, the previous [eau de vie] cask contents seemingly promoting the [allium-y] cowpats with further leanings towards tequila > mezcal. Perhaps that’s why I love this so whilst others not so much. Perhaps a curveball for a blind tequila line-up?
- F: With a further eau de vie injection, we finish with a now relaxed new make-y finish, [white] grape/wine-like, the oily viscosity continuing to envelop over the palate.
- C: To love this one is to appreciate raw spirit regardless of grain/cane/vine [or cask] origin, not an unreasonable challenge for someone with dedication to the pursuit of flavour & taste, to quality over quantity. This will, however, remain a weird/left-field whisky for those who tend to stick to particular single malt [Scotch] styles.
Scores 88 points
The common theme between all these four whiskies? Spirit-faithfulness with an immense intense crisp salty farmy hit, and tequila/mezcal/rum vibes throughout!
3 thoughts on “Have I Got News Four You: Revisiting Bruichladdich’s Peat Monsters”