A Wee Trip Over The Pond: Part 2/2

Following on from the first four [WLP], here are four more whiskey’s from across the pond.

Old Overholt 04yo [2020] Ob. Straight Rye Whiskey 114 Proof WB0

  • N: 114 proof is 57% abv and yet this is rather faint/light at first [and beyond], yet also fruity and [honeysuckle] floral too [in equal measure] – a rich black/red berry jammy fruitiness with a light lemon balm/lemon sponge note. Other baking layers speak of icing sugar, creamed icing, dried baking fruits, Iced Gems, vanilla-ey custard tarts. Fabulous! Later on, aside from all the berries, I pick up on a Scottish grain vibe.
  • T: Strong yet weirdly [spicy] soft at the same time. Starts spritely and nippy yet mysteriously still remains somewhat thin/delicate despite the abv, grainy, and fruity on [black/raspberry/red/sloe] berry juice with a suggestive [Bowmore 33yo WLP / cognac-esque] parma violet/soap note, a drop of confectionary vanilla cream, half a drop of maple syrup,… distant suggestions of fruity-menthol-> cinnamon Kingfisher toothpaste. There is some heat, but whether it’s an issue for you or not is another thing. At its [lower-shelf] price point, it’s absolutely acceptable.
  • F: From that light soft yet perky freshness we’ve an easy creamy fruity rye travel with a juicy [cask] savoury~berry-bitter dryness, with vanilla < cinnamon peppermint [toothpaste] and < fabric plasters at the death.
  • C: Nailed it if I do say so myself. Just as good as a 1980s expression [WLP84] I’ve reviewed in the last few years. As long as the price remains I’ll keep buying this glugger.

Scores 84 points


Four Roses Single Barrel [2022] Ob. Barrel #20-3A Warehouse #PS 50% [100 proof] WBWF[2013]:88 Ralfy[2013]:89 M-R:4/10 

  • N: Sweet oak-spiced buttered corn over scented roses, quince jelly, buttery custardy strawberry mousse, menthol-y < sawdusty cinnamon, a lovely crushed muddle of assorted gooey cakes & sponges, a touch of soy & sweet chilli sauce mixed with wasabi over pineapple and mango and a halva-like biscuity nuttiness,… On the flip side, it’s grainy and column-y with a complex thick vanilla biscuit/wafer dryness – all very appealing, attainable, commendable,… EDIT: I forgot to mention boozy buttered [white breaded] toast!
  • T: Confident/bombastic fresh [fine ground] petal-floral peppery oak arrival, some of the top notes not too far away from parma violets, raspberries, and Cherry Aid,…. before [plenty] more dry/not dry spirit graininess, eventually enveloping into a sort of boozy if complex-dry concoction of lemon & cucumber gin with grated courgettes, sweet grated carrot [cake], flat Baby Cham over vodka over Prosecco, dark cherry & orange chocolate…. fizzy yoghurty ice cream, classic [ethyl acetate?] acetone, sliced almonds in the mix, aniseed/spearmint, fennel or caraway seeds[?],… 
  • F: From an outsider’s perspective, I find it remains quite column-y at times. Eventually, from the dry yet still oily mild potato vodka savoury sweetness [if you will], comes an Elijah Craig-esque medicinal fusty blackberry > fungal note, though here it’s far lighter, somewhat bitter [oak tannins] – a dry-greasy/waxy mouth coating throughout. 
  • C: What’s not to like, even for a non-bourbon fan? Gotta view bourbon differently to whisky, I think. Kinda simple and certainly complex at the same time, a fabulous BFYB. Every batch is different mind you yet the consistency of quality and price remain.

Scores 87 points


I rarely buy much American whiskey/bourbon, or [Canadian] rye,… but WhistlePig is one that sticks in my memory since acquiring my first bottle in 2013 [for £85!] of which I still have samples. Tonight I shall have a sample of both, that older bottling, alongside a recent release. As a reminder, WhistlePig is Alberta-sourced [Canadian] rye whiskey aged in Vermont, Indiana.

WhistlePig 10yo [2013] Ob. Straight Rye Whiskey 100 proof/50% WB83.33[77] WF[2015]75

  • N: Withstanding imperfections, I find a lot of joy in the nose, overall, more rounded & relaxed [floppy] in comparison to the current release. Operating [in some respects] like a mature [if deliberately resinous] grain whisky, this WP displays a fruity papyrus < < Rivita fustiness, vanilla custard pastries = apple turnovers ~ > set honey, butterscotch tart [with burnt pastry], confectionary [hint of foam bananas] cacao~chocolate orange~[citrus] strawberry rubbery jammy marshmallows [meets candy banana > sherbet],.. sherry vibes [as I’d picked up 9 years previously],.. and a calvados-ey dryness.
  • T: Again, a looser arrival in comparison to its contemporary counterpart with a fruity spicy [apple & nutmeg crumble], [ever] rum-like firmly vanished [fruity=confectionary=plasticised] banana-ey raspberry = < strawberry flower floral & leafy [Grandma’s] soap, and a sourness,…. unfolding with a [slightly peculiar if personally desirable] charred dry fatty greasiness. Further fruitiness – notes of redcurrants and blueberries [chalky Tunes] – continue to sing. Like the contemporary bottling to follow, water is not required unless desired. 
  • F: A middling/culminating finish, slightly waxy dryish [liquorice floury oily~linseed-y] yet chewy mouthfeel,…. a desirable light lingering spice with a vanilla-ey barley sugar-like conclusion, the candy theme continuing into a root beer-likeness, still with some banana foam and sherbet. In comparison to its contemporary counterpart, here, the char is slight.
  • C: Comes across as more cobbled together in comparison to the current expression, some for the good, some less so. I remain rather keen on it even if my early scores were,…. naively optimistic.

Scores 85 points


We finish with two back-to-back bottles of WhistlePig’s latest 10yo release. Despite being different-sized bottles, as with the batch code, the whiskey was identical.

WhistlePig 10yo [2022] Ob. Rye Whiskey Batch A/354 100 proof/50% [375ml and 70cl bottles] WB83.67[12]/WB67[1] [WF’15]75 M-R5/10 connosr86[12]

  • N: Overall, compared to its predecessor, this is a sharper/more focused even astringent experience with a rather new oak-spicy scorched/charred situation. Exploring it more, it’s a fruity number with descriptors along the lines of lemon tangerine~strawberry [actual fruits & confectionary], spirity vanilla custard pastries, ginger cake >  rose water,…. stock cubes? I like!
  • T: Far sharper, focused [narrower] arrival in comparison to the predecessor though similarities in character remain. With some sips, I think “what’s all the fuss about”, followed by an opposing perspective of a quality whiskey with delicacy and depth that talks of papaya lemony orange > gingery >~ rose water~Turkish Delight < lychee juice,…
  • F: Clean, [column-like] ‘easy’ burned sugary-sweet spirity dry-ish vanilla finish.
  • C: Subjectively, I prefer the older bottling though both are just as good in different ways. Ordering another bottle straight after finishing the last tells you something.

Scores 85 points


One thought on “A Wee Trip Over The Pond: Part 2/2

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s