Benromach: De-constructed

Benromach now
The prettiest bits of Benromach in 2016

The Benromach distillery based in Forres was officially opened in 1900, though some at the distillery say it was 1895. Like many distilleries, it had it’s fair share of stop-starts in production, name changes [it was called Forres between 1907-1910], and take-overs right up until it’s rebuilding/expansion program in the 1960’s and again in the 1970’s when much of the pretty aesthetics and artitecture of the old distillery were removed [including the pagoda/cupola SW], and the remaining buildings whitewashed.

The distillery along with swathes of others closed in 1983.

Benromach then.jpg
The Benromach distillery in the early 1900’s

Boby mill.jpg

When G&M bought Benromach at the beginning of 1993, they found the dormant distillery had been quite the popular local hangout. It took five years to clean up [thousands of fag butts and [Tennant’s] beer cans], and install virtually all new equipment – so the distillery was effectively re-built once again. The only pieces that had survived from the 1983 closure were the spirit receiver and the cast iron Boby mill [left]. The mill is suitably big enough for Benromach’s modest needs even with the planned expansion going ahead this year [2017].

G&M in partnership with the Urquhart family were clear from the outset that they would be producing a more traditional style of Speyside whisky. Benromach’s small scale was key to this vision. The distillery currently produces around 235,000 litres a year, slightly more than Kilchoman [200,000], and the yet to be opened Harris [210,000]. They use only 100% Scottish grain and peat-wise, their peated/malted barley contains 10-12 ppm which translates as 3-4ppm in the bottle.

Another key element in producing a traditional style of malt is the yeast. Benromach claim to be the only distillery using a combination of Distiller’s and Brewer’s yeast. Further afield in America, ‘Four Roses use five different strains on two mash bills to create ten different new-makes’, explains Dave Broom,…. and in Japan, ‘Nikka coyly says it uses around five strains. Suntory, too, has a selection of different yeasts for its makes’ SW. Back in Scotland, the Dornoch distillery has been experimenting with many traditional yeast strains way before it’s official opening in 2016 and i’m sure we shall see many more distilleries re-investing efforts in varied yeast strains before too long.

Regarding the fermentation, Benromach have both a long and a short cycle. The short fermentation is around two days, the long fermentation up to five. Both washes are then mixed together before being sent to the still house.

The first distillation abv-wise [from the wash still], is a calculation worked out using the temperature over density of the spirit. The heart [collected when the spirit runs clear], is approximately 2000 litres or 20% and starts at around 72°. The tails is anything below 62°.

Benromach have a neat weekly cycle from grain to cask. The process is thus:

  • Mill – A weeks worth of milling on the Boby is done on day 1
  • Mash tun – That weeks worth of grist fills the one mash tun for a weeks worth of wort.
  • Washbacks – The wort fills the four washbacks [with the longer fermentation cycle taking up to five days].
  • Stills – The wash is received by one pair of stills that produce up to 9000 litres of spirit.
  • Casks – At the end of the week they can fill 18 butts, 33 hogsheads or 35 barrels. Benromach predominantly fill a lot of European sherry hogsheads.
Prince Charles cask.jpg
Cask #1 owned by the Prince of Wales

Benromach only use first fill cask for their spirit. They openly admit this is to speed up the process for fulfilling their quota/demand for the standard 10yo. The casks are then send away as refills for use by G&M’s other projects. The small warehouse we were taken to had enough space for 3 weeks worth of cask fills. Theres no dunnage or indeed any fustiness given the cool yet dry concrete floor in this modern barn-style warehouse, so there maybe an absence of foosy notes in Prince Charles’s cask #1.


The de-construction [and re-construction], of the standard 10yo 43%

Benromach tasting ME alone.jpg

The standard 10yo is made up of a large percentage of 9yo sherry matured whisky and a smaller percentage of 9yo bourbon matured whisky, finished for 18 months in oloroso casks – all first-fill. It’s then watered down using de-ionised water, re-married, left to rest and then finally bottled. We got to try the constituent parts that went in to making the 10yo before trying the finished article and its older brother, the 15yo. The only substantial missing link in this enlightening tasting was the absence of the new-make spirit which i always find illuminates the understanding of the final product.

Benromach 9yo First-fill bourbon CS 58.9%

As Benromach only use first fill casks, this relatively young juice at cask strength is likely to be punchy.

  • N: You can literally smell the cask and those modern efficiency-prepared oak staves. Not sure there’s much of the spirit’s character to be gleaned here, just a passing whiff of apple pips. With water and time, clearer fruit notes appear – namely  apples & pears, soft pears.
  • T: This is brash stuff, fruity & grassy before evidence of that 10-12 ppm peated barley finally emerges.
  • F: Now there’s an oily/tar quality [from the peat, char?], before the appearance of smoke only. There are greener notes with water. Concludes with a smokey barley finish.
  • C: Quite harsh and raw at times, mainly speaking of that fresh, new ‘tech’ oak. Let’s move on to the sherry casks.

Benromach 9yo First-fill sherry cask CS 59%

  • N: This is a savoury, meaty-Bovril sherry nose.
  • T: Coal tar, charcoal, BBQ bacon,….. dry overall.
  • F: Grassy, raw and unripe actually with green fruits – apples to greengages.
  • C: Like the bourbon 9yo, it’s the young wood that speaks loudly. The resulting sherry cask influence is rather varied from nose to palate to finish, which is no bad thing. Let’s try the two 9yo’s combined, then finished in oloroso casks.

Benromach 10yo CS 57.6%

So this is a malt blend of the 9yo bourbon & 9yo sherry casks [all first-fill], finished for 18 months in oloroso and presented at cask strength.

  • N: It’s still very raw and pokey but that oloroso finish has rounded off the edges somewhat. Adding water bring out the rubbery [erasers] raisins. There’s a little smoke.
  • T: A little more rubbery>erasers.
  • F: The actual oloroso comes out clearly now as does the light barley smoke with a lasting vegetal sour-cream note.
  • C: Take away the oloroso roundness factor and you still have a raw & boisterous whisky. The high abv isn’t helping the cause, but let’s remember this is still not the finished article 10yo – reduced to 43%, married, rested and then bottled. It’s up next.

Benromach 10yo [2016] Ob. [bar: S020613023680] 43% WB85.21[385] WF87 WM83[6]’12

Benromach 10yo.png

  • N: It is the sum of its parts but the abv reduction has tempered much of the rawness by rounding off those rough oak edges whilst softening the impact of the oloroso directly. It’s even possible to detect the bourbon notes from the sherried ones, having done the de-construction.
  • T: Soft rubbery, bouncy chew. The rawness has been ‘sherry-disguised’. The peat level is just enough.
  • F: Familiar cask-sour notes.
  • C: This certainly is the finished article. There’s still a rawness but a rounded rawness, and it doesn’t just taste like sherry – hence a good mix. It’s a very well constructed malt and all the better for those phenols, though I’m happy for more.

Scores 86 points.

Benromach 15yo [2016] Ob. 43% WB85.43[121] WF86

Benromach 15yo.jpg

  • N: So this is the ‘baked’ 10yo. As a result it’s far richer with some varnish notes.
  • T: Even at 43%, a drop of water is desirable as those first fill casks still have some fire in their staves.
  • F: Vegetal bitter [Talisker-esque 18yo], and oloroso cask sour.
  • C: I’m on maraca’s with both the 10yo and the 15yo. I find the 15yo better in some ways but both are equally as good.

Scores 86 points.

Benromach ‘re-construction’

C: This wasn’t part of the program but my ‘master blender’ gene kicked in. I proceeded to mix my samples of the 9yo bourbon, the 9yo sherry and the 10yo CS, then married them for around five minutes in a glass with a splash of water. What became apparent is how important dilution is, equal to the oloroso influence on rounding off the sharp edges in conjunction with good marrying time.

What an insight this de-construction tasting has been, an insight into the complexities that go into making ‘standard’ expressions and the blending skills required to execute such a presentation. We call these single malts, but blending of all the different components is what makes the mark.

Nick and i.jpg

Thank you to Rebecca [from Benromach], and the Whisky Lounge team for this experience.

Further reading: MM SW

Comments are closed.